The Eddie Livingstone Trophy is awarded to the league's regular season champion. It was first awarded for Season Eleven.
| Season | Winner(s) |
|---|---|
| 21 | Sault Surge (GM: Kevin Laitinen) |
| 20 | North Dakota Nighthawks (GM: Andrew G) |
| 19 | Toronto Marlboros (GM: Matt Gelowitz) |
| 18 | Ottawa Valley Wolfhounds (GM: Cory Jordan) |
| 17 | Sault Surge (GM: Kevin Laitinen) |
| 16 | Fort Worth Fighting Squirrels (GM: Brian Stewart) |
| 15 | Ottawa Valley Wolfhounds (GM: Cory Jordan) |
| 14 | Michigan Sentinels (GM: Clark Rasmussen) |
| 13 | Ottawa Valley Wolfhounds (GM: Cory Jordan) |
| 12 | Sault Surge (GM: Kevin Laitinen) |
| 11 | Portland Huskies (GM: Jenny Jensen) |